top of page

Amazing Food Stops in Patchogue, NY

Updated: Jan 12

Patchogue is a small town founded in the 1700's situated along the Great South Bay, rich in history and great people.

Apart from beautiful bodies of water, boating, fishing, hunting, and staying in vacation homes, there are amazing food stops in Patchogue that anyone should never miss. Here are some of our favorites so far:

Kilwin's Chocolates

Started by Don and Katy Kilwin in 1947, their love for making chocolates is truly felt with the products that they offer.

Caramel Apples

Caramel Apples at Kilwin's Patchogue from Kyle Kelly's 12 Days of a Patchogue Christmas

One would go in awe with the wide variety of caramel apples that Kilwin's offers. Among the crowd favorites are: The Perfect Apple - a classic Granny Smith covered in copper-kettle caramel with the perfect crunch and sweetness. If you are looking for something with some sweet, nutty, buttery flavor, the Pecan Turtle Caramel Apple is the one for you. For a mixture of sweet and salty, try the Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel Apple covered in Kilwin's Heritage Milk Chocolate finished with sea salt.

Want to see more Kilwin's goodies? Here's a quick peek inside Kilwin's Patchogue:

Old-fashioned confectionery? Chocolates? Ice cream? Handmade sweets? Gift baskets? You can find them all here:

Kilwins Patchogue Village

Service options: Curbside pickup

Landmark: Patchogue-Medford Library

Address: 74 E Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772

Phone: +1 631-627-8584


Donatina's Pizza

Craving for brick oven pizza? Donatina's is one of the best places to get pizzas in town! Patchogue Mayor Paul Pontieri's favorite is the Meat Lover's Pizza. It has San Marzano sauce, mozzarella, Italian ham, meatballs, pepperoni, hot and sweet sausage, and grated pepperoni with extra virgin olive oil. Their pizzas are cooked in a classic, dome-shaped, brick oven at very high temperatures.

Baking the pizza in the brick oven

One thing that tells a good slice of pepperoni is when it curls up from the heat. That's a nice fresh pepperoni. A good pizza is something that you want to eat as soon as it comes out of the oven, take it just the way it comes out – perfect. (If you like it extra hot, it’s pleasant to dip it in Mike's Hot Honey.)

Kyle Kelly enjoying a slice of the Meat Lover's Pizza

More of Donatina's Pizza:

Want to get some fresh hand-made pizzas, pasta, and hero sandwiches while in Patchogue? Just head over to:

Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe

Service options: Dine-in · Takeout · Delivery

Address: 18 West Ave, Patchogue, NY 11772

Phone: +1 631-730-7002

Gallo Restaurant

Started by the Bustamante family in 2002, this restaurant serves hearty meals enjoyed in Colombia for generations. The recipes they follow have been around for hundreds of years and the ingredients that they use are fresh. To add to that, they have heaps of drink selections, too!

Not Your Ordinary Empanada

Gallo empanadas are amazing. They get their own corn and grind them to create that beautiful and tasty masa. They are filled with potatoes and cooked the Colombian way. Whether you are a vegetarian or not, you will definitely love these bites!

Potato-filled corn empanadas from Gallo Restaurant

Finger Foods

A platter of everything you can dream of is probably the best way to describe Gallo's platter of finger foods. It has steak, pork sausage, chicharon, chorizo, tostones (fried plantains), and a little bit of everything that you can enjoy with their avocado sauce. Delicious!

A platter of Colombian warmth

Enjoying great food at Gallo:

Homestyle Colombian platters? Mexican dishes? A festive vibe? Cocktails, sangria, and other drinks? Gallo is the place to be:


Address: 3 E Main St, Patchogue, NY 11772


Phone: +1 631-475-4667

Interested in moving to Patchogue? Growing a business or moving to a different city? Give us a call, a text, or an email. We would love to help you!

Disclaimer: Views and information provided in this post are for general informational and educational purposes only and is not a substitute for professional advice. Before taking any action based upon such information, we encourage you to consult with the appropriate professionals. The use or reliance to any information contained on this site or mobile application is solely at your own risk.

Blue and Pink Modern Tech Electronics and Technology Retractable Exhibition Banner (6).png
bottom of page